Steven
Barnaby
Your trusted real estate agent in Payson, Arizona. Deep local knowledge, responsive service, and a straightforward approach to every transaction.
Try HaloKnow what your cabin, home, or land is really worth in today's Rim Country market.
Find Your Place in the Pines
Browse live listings across Payson, Pine, Strawberry, and all of Rim Country. No login needed.
Average days on market across Rim Country, per the Central Arizona Association of REALTORS (CAAR).
Living and working
in Rim Country.
From the ponderosa pines to the Mogollon Rim, Steven brings detailed local knowledge of Payson's neighborhoods and surrounding Rim Country communities. His local knowledge, combined with 3+ years and 33+ successful transactions, means you get an agent who truly understands the land and the market.
Real estate with
real integrity.
Steven got into real estate because he wanted to help people navigate one of the biggest decisions of their lives. He is committed to laying out the pros and cons of every transaction so his clients can make informed choices with confidence.
A retired Navy LCDR with an Electrical Engineering degree from Penn State and a Masters from the Naval Postgraduate School, Steven brings sharp attention to detail, leadership skills, and down-to-earth integrity to every deal.
Read Steven's full story“The average days on market is approximately 134 days, with nearly 19% of listings taking more than four months to sell.”
Featured Listings
Two active listings from Steven in the Payson area. Each property comes with the full picture, the pros and the cons, so you can decide with confidence.
Active Listing
191 N Cornerstone Way
- Horse property on 2 fully fenced acres
- Remodeled kitchen, 30x30 insulated shop with 4-car garage
- Horse corral, RV parking, and solar
- No HOA and a private well
Active Listing
510 E Evergreen St
- Cozily updated 2 bed / 2 bath home
- Fenced yard with sheds
- Permitted garage
These listings are represented by Steven Barnaby of eXp Realty. Contact Steven for current status, pricing, and showing availability.
How Steven Helps
Home Buyers
Whether it is your first home or your forever home, Steven walks you through every step so you can buy with confidence.
Read the buyer’s guideHome Sellers
Pricing strategy, marketing, and negotiation that gets results. Steven lays out the pros and cons so you make informed decisions.
Read the seller’s guideFirst-Time Buyers
The process can feel overwhelming. Steven makes it simple, explains every document, and ensures you understand each choice.
Relocating to Payson
Moving from out of state? Steven brings detailed local knowledge of Payson's neighborhoods, school zones, and hidden gems in Rim Country to help you find the right fit.
Military discipline.
Small-town heart.
Retired Navy LCDR. Electrical Engineering degree from Penn State. Masters degree from the Naval Postgraduate School. Steven's military background means meticulous preparation, clear communication, and a calm steadiness when deals get complex.
But what clients value most is his responsiveness, deep local knowledge of the Payson, Pine, Strawberry, Christopher Creek, Tonto Basin, Verde Estates, Fountain Hills, and Star Valley communities, and an easy-going personality that makes every transaction smooth and stress-free.
Recent Sales
Most recently closed by Steven Barnaby in Rim Country.
816 W Longhorn Rd
508 S Manzanita Dr
606 S Mud Springs Rd
311 N Clark Rd
6737 W Kachina Cir
903 N Deer Creek
Closed sales represented by Steven Barnaby of eXp Realty. Sale prices shown are the final recorded sale amounts.
What Clients Say
"Steve is highly skilled and patient with his clients. He is consistently responsive and always focused on finding the best possible solutions for their needs."
"Steve was amazing. He was very through, he got me into contact with the right people. I was amazed at how seamless the home buying process was with the help of Steve. He was great at communicating, he got me in touch with the right people. I would definitely recommend his services to anyone looking at buying a home or selling."
"Steven made our home buying experience stress-free. His local knowledge of Payson is unmatched, and he always had our best interests at heart."
"We were relocating from out of state and Steven guided us through every step. He laid out all our options clearly so we could make the right choice for our family."
"Professional, responsive, and genuinely cares about his clients. Steven's attention to detail made all the difference in our sale."
"Steve is very knowledgeable. He's very friendly and thorough. I would recommend him to anyone."
"I highly recommend Steve he is very helpful and knowledgeable of the Payson area real-estate. He was always readily available to address any and all of my questions."
"The minute I met Steve, I just liked him! Easy-going easy to talk to and sharp as a tack! In all my years of buying homes, this is the first time it felt like my agent truly had my back and was looking out for me, and asking all kinds of questions that I never even thought to ask. The next homes I purchase will definitely be through Steve Barnaby! And for now, since our homebuying is done, he will now become just a good friend."
Serving Rim Country
Payson sits at 5,000 feet in the Ponderosa pines, just 90 minutes from Phoenix. Steven knows every corner of Rim Country and the communities that make it special.
Payson
The heart of Rim Country. Mountain living with small-town charm.
Pine
A quiet mountain community surrounded by Ponderosa pines.
Strawberry
Historic mountain charm near the Tonto Natural Bridge.
Christopher Creek
Rustic cabins and creek-side living along the Mogollon Rim.
Tonto Basin
Rural Arizona living near Roosevelt Lake with boating, fishing, and lakefront property.
Verde Estates
Peaceful residential living in the heart of Rim Country.
Fountain Hills
A scenic desert community near the McDowell Mountains with resort-style living.
Star Valley
Quiet mountain living along the Tonto Creek corridor with cabins, ranch properties, and easy access to Payson.
Rim Country
The broader Mogollon Rim region and surrounding communities.
Rim Country Insights
Tips, guides, and local knowledge from Steven to help you navigate the Rim Country real estate market with confidence.
Payson's Fall 2026 Housing Market: New Starter Homes, Rising Inventory, and What It Means for Buyers and Sellers
Habitat for Humanity is bringing starter homes to Payson, a 74-unit affordable apartment community is moving forward, and inventory keeps climbing. Here is what the fall 2026 market means for buyers and sellers across Rim Country.
Read Article
Winterizing Your Rim Country Cabin: The Complete Pre-Winter Checklist for Payson, Pine, Strawberry, and Heber-Overgaard
First hard freezes arrive by late October in Rim Country. Here is the complete winterization checklist for cabins in Payson, Pine, Strawberry, and Heber-Overgaard, plus what winter reveals to buyers and sellers.
Read Article
October in Rim Country: Fair Week, Peak Fall Color, and a Market That Keeps Tilting Toward Buyers
Fair week opens October 1, fall color peaks on the Rim in mid-October, and the market keeps tilting toward buyers. Your month-ahead guide to Payson, Pine, Strawberry, and Rim Country.
Read ArticleQuick answers for buyers and sellers.
From cabin prices to well water and HOA rules, here are the questions Steven hears most from buyers and sellers across Rim Country.
What does a cabin in Payson cost?
Median home prices are running roughly $420,000 to $495,000, with entry-level cabins and manufactured homes on land well below that range.
Read the answerHow much does land cost in Rim Country?
Raw land across Gila County runs roughly $20,000 to $60,000 per acre, while smaller town-adjacent lots are priced much higher per acre.
Read the answerWhat should I know about water and wells?
Water is the most important question on any mountain property, and well permits can be difficult to obtain in parts of Gila County.
Read the answer
Ready to find your
place in Rim Country?
Whether you are buying your first home, selling a property, or relocating to Payson, Steven is ready to help. Reach out today for a no-pressure conversation.